Ultimate Potato Salad Recipe

There's nothing quite like a bowl of classic potato salad at a backyard barbecue or picnic. Creamy, tangy, and packed with flavor, this ultimate version is everything you love about the traditional dish—with just a few small tweaks that make it totally irresistible.

I still remember the first time I brought this to a family cookout. What started as a simple side dish turned into the star of the table, with everyone asking for seconds—and the recipe. Whether you're hosting a gathering or meal prepping for the week, this potato salad delivers comfort, nostalgia, and a punch of flavor in every bite.

This creamy, hearty salad comes together with pantry staples, fresh herbs, and a few tricks to make it extra delicious. Let’s dig into what makes it so special.

Why You'll Love This Ultimate Potato Salad

Get ready to meet your new go-to side dish. This Ultimate Potato Salad is the kind of recipe you'll come back to again and again—and not just for summer parties.

It’s quick and easy to make. Don’t let the word “ultimate” intimidate you—this dish comes together in under 45 minutes, with most of the time spent waiting for potatoes to cool. It’s a straightforward process that’s perfect for even beginner cooks.

It’s perfect for feeding a crowd. Whether you're prepping for a potluck, picnic, or Sunday dinner, this recipe makes enough to serve 8–10 generous portions. And the best part? It’s even better the next day after the flavors have had time to mingle.

It’s budget-friendly and made with everyday ingredients. No fancy shopping trips required here. This potato salad uses simple items you probably already have in your kitchen—just good-quality mayo, mustard, vinegar, and a few fresh veggies.

It’s incredibly customizable. From extra-crispy bacon to chopped pickles or hard-boiled eggs, you can tailor this recipe to suit your crowd’s taste buds or whatever ingredients you have on hand.

Once you make it this way, you may never go back to store-bought again. Let's take a closer look at what you’ll need.

Ingredients Notes

The magic of this Ultimate Potato Salad comes down to classic ingredients used thoughtfully. Each component adds texture, richness, or that signature tangy-sweet balance potato salad is known for.

The potatoes are the heart of this dish. I love using Yukon Golds—they're creamy, slightly buttery, and hold their shape beautifully after boiling. If you're in a pinch, red potatoes are another great choice. Avoid Russets, which can fall apart and get mealy.

The mayonnaise forms the creamy base of the dressing. Go for full-fat, good-quality mayo—it makes a difference. For a lighter version, you can swap in half Greek yogurt, but you’ll sacrifice a bit of that classic flavor.

Mustard and vinegar add brightness and zip. I use a mix of Dijon mustard and apple cider vinegar, which gives the salad a tangy bite that cuts through the richness. A dash of sugar balances everything out without making it sweet.

Celery and red onion bring crunch and color. Finely chopped, they add just the right amount of sharpness and texture without overwhelming the dish. If raw onion is too strong for your taste, soak it in cold water for 10 minutes before mixing it in.

Hard-boiled eggs add a bit of extra protein and richness. I like to chop mine roughly so you get a bit in every bite. They're optional, but I highly recommend including them if you’re going for that old-school deli-style flavor.

You won’t need any fancy tools here—just a big pot, a mixing bowl, and a sharp knife. If you have a potato masher or ricer, you can use it lightly for a slightly mashed texture, but it's not essential.

How To Make This Ultimate Potato Salad

Making a killer potato salad is all about timing and layering flavor. Let’s walk through it together.

Start by scrubbing your potatoes and cutting them into evenly sized chunks, about 1 to 1.5 inches each. Place them in a large pot and cover with cold, salted water. Bring to a boil, then reduce to a simmer. Cook until the potatoes are fork-tender but not falling apart—about 10 to 12 minutes.

While the potatoes are cooking, take a few minutes to prep your other ingredients. Dice your celery and red onion, and chop up any herbs you're using (fresh dill and parsley are my favorites). Hard-boil your eggs, if you're including them, and peel once cooled.

Once the potatoes are done, drain them and spread them out on a baking sheet or large bowl to cool slightly. Here’s a pro tip: sprinkle a little apple cider vinegar on the warm potatoes. They’ll absorb the flavor and add a delicious tangy base.

While the potatoes cool, mix together your dressing. Combine mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, vinegar, a touch of sugar, salt, and black pepper in a large mixing bowl. Stir in your celery, onion, chopped eggs, and any herbs.

When the potatoes are just warm—not hot—fold them gently into the dressing. Be careful not to overmix; you want them coated but still intact. The dressing may seem thick at first, but it will loosen as it sits and mingles with the potato starch.

Cover and chill for at least one hour, though overnight is even better. The flavors meld together beautifully with a little time, and the result is creamy, flavorful perfection in every forkful.

Storage Options

This potato salad stores beautifully, making it ideal for prepping ahead.

In the fridge, it keeps well in an airtight container for up to 4 days. In fact, it often tastes better after a day or two, as the flavors deepen and the potatoes fully absorb the dressing.

Avoid freezing, though—the creamy dressing doesn’t hold up well in the freezer and can become watery and separated when thawed.

If you’re transporting it to a picnic or potluck, be sure to keep it chilled in a cooler with ice packs. Food safety is key, especially when dealing with mayo-based salads in warm weather.

To reheat, well… you don’t! Potato salad is best served cold or at room temperature. Just give it a stir before serving, and top with a sprinkle of fresh herbs for a little fresh pop.

Variations and Substitutions

One of the best things about this Ultimate Potato Salad is how easy it is to tweak to your liking.

Want some extra richness? Add crispy bacon. Stir in a few slices of cooked, crumbled bacon for a smoky, salty addition that takes this salad to another level.

Looking for crunch? Try adding diced dill pickles or pickle relish. They add a zesty, vinegary bite that plays beautifully with the creamy dressing.

Not a fan of mayo? You can substitute part of the mayo with sour cream or Greek yogurt. The result is still creamy, but with a slightly tangier profile that some people love.

For a herby twist, try mixing in chopped fresh chives or tarragon instead of the usual parsley or dill. These herbs add subtle but surprising flavor.

And if you're making it vegan? Simply swap the mayo for a plant-based version, skip the eggs, and load up on extra veggies like bell peppers or peas for color and texture.

The beauty of this dish is that once you’ve got the base down, you can play with it endlessly. Don’t be afraid to experiment until you find your signature version!

Print